Discover more from The Sociology of Business
Luxury Fashion’s Challenges
A version of this article was originally featured on Luxury Daily, on December 10th 2018.
Fashion has long employed the wait-and-see approach to its own change. Sometimes that means weathering the trends (Crocs, anyone?), and other times missing them and having to play catch up (sneakers, e-commerce, customer experience). If we had to outline the biggest challenges for the global fashion industry right now, they would be among the following.
Luxury fashion industry’s biggest internal challenge is its outdated organizational structure. Notable examples aside, fashion brands are still mostly hierarchical, heavily siloed enterprises, where departments often compete with each other for clout and resources. Blame the old PR-merchandising complex, where both PR and merchandising wielded the outsized influence on what gets made and pushed into the hands of consumers. When the consumer is hyper-connected, informed, and fickle, this organizational format and its power centers do not cut it anymore. Fashion companies direly need to become always-on, responsive organizations that have no difficulty sharing data and intelligence from different teams, integrating their online and offline touchpoints, and organizing around their customer journey.
Luxury fashion is has so far weathered successfully the China tariffs war, but is still faced with a number of external challenges. Transformation of the physical stores is on the top of the list, with only a limited number of brands actively modernizing their physical retail spaces. There is much left to be desired in terms of a seamless customer experience (start with a free in-store wifi, continue with technology empowered customer service), data integration and CRM, options for Apple and Ali Pay, and for quickly locating and delivering products to customers across stores and fulfillment centers. This technology-powered customer experience is accompanied by a broader shift in the culture of luxury stores. GUCCI is one of the rare brands that successfully changed the “you can’t sit with us” vibe prevalent in many of the luxury fashion establishment into welcoming and comfortable setting with couches, easily accessible and touchable products, water and coffee, and no-commission salespeople that are there mostly to helpfully chat with you.
After showing up early to the party some years ago, social commerce is making its resolute comeback. Instagram’s shopping app will emphasize what and whose look people are buying, not where are they buying it from. If anyone has been paying attention what’s going on over at Depop, they’d be able to glimpse a future where the sellers are also the stylists, the models, the community hubs, and micro-influencers all at the same time.
Moving down the list, luxury fashion still has yet to crack the code of experiential consumption and evolve its business models and revenue streams so it can be profitable even before the consumer makes a single product purchase. For the industry whose revenues heavily depend on product sales, this is a massive challenge. But with younger consumers spending less and less on physical goods and more and more on their own personal transformation, well-being, and experiences, luxury fashion needs to diversify its money-making tactics.
On December 6th, Burberry announced its collaboration with Vivienne Westwood, mostly prompting questions of why it didn’t happen sooner. Collaborations in fashion are the new competition, as long as they make sense for both brands in terms of their shared cultural territory.
Luxury fashion has been obsessed with streetwear for a while now, but it hardly moved this obsession beyond products like hoodies and sneakers into the retail models and communication tactics promoted by streetwear. Now we are seeing brands tentatively testing the waters with drops, like Burberry and GUCCI did earlier this year. Limited editions are yet to be unlocked, and fast, as young consumers are obsessed with exclusivity. There’s much to learned from Supreme, which mastered the art of distinction. In this model, a brand is an umbrella for a portfolio of unique products, where a large part of its audience own unique brand products and the limited number of people owns the exact same thing.
For the first time ever, luxury fashion is now also directly competing with everyone from Supreme to Nike to Adidas to Yeezy to GOOP. Casualization and mixing formalwear with streetwear is only partly to blame. Cultural currency around high-end products has now expanded to styling, a personal point of view, uniqueness, and a social message rather than having a head-to-toe designer look.
The ideas of masculinity and femininity are changing as well, and luxury fashion brands have to adapt. The James Bond alpha-males are no longer the status symbol, nor are hyper-sexualized clothes for women, if the consumer backlash after Hedi Slimane’s first Celine collection is any indicator. Women want to dress based on their own perception of their own identity, and so do men. Today, this perception is evolving and fluid. Like GUCCI and Balenciaga show, campaign imagery and brand ambassadors who once fit into the neat gender categories and represented masculine or feminine ideals feel increasingly irrelevant and old-fashioned. While a lot of luxury fashion brands talk about millennials and tout their millennial-first strategy, the real challenge is switching it into execution.